Divisions - Discussion/Questions....
-
Basically you are going to take away manager points for a more fairer way of ranking you think? Also using 4 accounts will make OSM managers more active and a truer rank? Both assumptions but think Iβm right, I canβt see a logical reason for the swap otherwise apart from these two reasons. I donβt expect a reply, hard questions I know. Just ignore me as per, Iβm used to it
@SpecialOneThe new way with medals is flawed a lot worse. You will get loads more cheaters and inactive leagues BUT they also donβt have to cheat to get above good managers that play in competitive leagues. This is the main flaw people are bothered about! Iβve read this off a few managers on this post with screen shots and it doesnβt seem to be sinking in. See @Restimat last post
So letβs talk money and BC spends, thatβs yours and OSMs language, see how much these new high ranked managers will bring to the table.......
Easy way to get high ranked just pay 200 BCs to set a league up, lock it up, donβt buy/sell and build teams, donβt use TCs, donβt speed timers and BC compensation then itβs very cheap and can win every game and more importantly not losing loads of medals for a loss! Youβre getting the reverse effect of trying to get people using 4 accounts and BC spends for ranking with lots of managers in each league.
Result in the long run you will get very high ranked managers that spend little on the game. We all know itβs about the money/BC spends with OSM. Why BC compensation is still on in app battles even if it makes them unfair
-
@SpecialOne Hey mate, I agree on that the old MP ranking needed an update and I see that the new medal ranking is perhaps a better setup, because all slots are used for the total. I also understand that the higher you get the more difficult it will be to score medals.
I only think that the majority of managers playing in crews want to have the medals excluded for all official crew events, like battles, CCW, FMS or Crew leagues. Is that possible to implement?You give yourself as an example, but you have to be honest that you or any of your crew mates don't play the same amount of battles other more active crews do. (and playing the crew league isn't too hard for you for a long time, because you always end up at the top
)Another suggestion I have is to implement a bonus for playing against a TC and draw or win without using a TC yourself. A lot of managers in higher divisions are facing managers from lower divisions an get a lot of TCs against, making it very hard to counter all of them. Getting some extra medals for having good results in those matches seems more fair to me.
btw I see that OSM staff is finally cleaning up the top ranking. keep it up!
You can either blame everybody else or you can take a look at yourself and determine where you can improve.
-
@wenger-wise said in Divisions - Discussion/Questions....:
as an option: post information about their old rating in the profile of all managers (as you did with the crews, though now I don't see it ...) and add some icon or something like that for those who have the achievement "Top-100", because obviously you will also take it away as a 10k point achievement for the season
Maintain an history about rankings on every slot will be something difficult, but final call wasn't taken yet.
Top 100 achievement, will remain, same way as other achievements that were removed already remained on managers profile!and really hope you fix these new medals somehow, because the top 3 are all banned right now - not sure if this is the best advertisement for new players
Everything on OSM (and on all games) is being updated constantly - if we wait for a final version to make it live, you'll never improve anything, because nothing in life is perfect
With this comment I mean that Manager Medals/ranking is a on going project -
@dennis-s-bergkamp said in Divisions - Discussion/Questions....:
I only think that the majority of managers playing in crews want to have the medals excluded for all official crew events, like battles, CCW, FMS or Crew leagues. Is that possible to implement?
Not really sure if this is the way to go. The only possibility I see here is to add another setting when requesting leagues, so league mods can enable/disable it. It will require also adjustments on signing up, because it will have to be clear that Medals are active or not. On the specific situation of crew battles, it will have to be ALL on or ALL off....
On a personal opinion I think that if we change, we should go for a change on calculation of win/draw/loss medals according with managers division and also end of season medals calculation.
You give yourself as an example, but you have to be honest that you or any of your crew mates don't play the same amount of battles other more active crews do. (and playing the crew league isn't too hard for you for a long time, because you always end up at the top
)Are you saying that "The Force" crew league is an easy league ? How many did you won in the 9 seasons you played there
? And don't forget that I always play with the lowest goal team on crew league
You should play a few more to make me lose 4K (2 * 2K) on every season
In case someone wants to try it, just drop me a line This is the list of League and cup winners and also managers who did the double on the 138 seasons we already played (I know, I know.... I'm abusing my position and advertising my league)
Another suggestion I have is to implement a bonus for playing against a TC and draw or win without using a TC yourself. A lot of managers in higher divisions are facing managers from lower divisions an get a lot of TCs against, making it very hard to counter all of them. Getting some extra medals for having good results in those matches seems more fair to me.
This is something that's already being considered
No promises, but who knows what future will bring btw I see that OSM staff is finally cleaning up the top ranking. keep it up!
Tks! As some of you know, we doesn't punish users without strong evidences and these cases require an access level to info that staff doesn't have, so it's always necessary the help of Gamebasics. This is why punishing these managers take longer than we would like and also why we prefer to work towards discourage this kind of cheating (an on going project) and educate our users!
"Success is not final, failure is not fatal: it is the courage to continue that counts." --Winston Churchill
-
@specialone said in Divisions - Discussion/Questions....:
@dennis-s-bergkamp said in Divisions - Discussion/Questions....:
I only think that the majority of managers playing in crews want to have the medals excluded for all official crew events, like battles, CCW, FMS or Crew leagues. Is that possible to implement?
Not really sure if this is the way to go. The only possibility I see here is to add another setting when requesting leagues, so league mods can enable/disable it. It will require also adjustments on signing up, because it will have to be clear that Medals are active or not. On the specific situation of crew battles, it will have to be ALL on or ALL off....
On a personal opinion I think that if we change, we should go for a change on calculation of win/draw/loss medals according with managers division and also end of season medals calculation.
You give yourself as an example, but you have to be honest that you or any of your crew mates don't play the same amount of battles other more active crews do. (and playing the crew league isn't too hard for you for a long time, because you always end up at the top
)Are you saying that "The Force" crew league is an easy league ? How many did you won in the 9 seasons you played there
? And don't forget that I always play with the lowest goal team on crew league
You should play a few more to make me lose 4K (2 * 2K) on every season
In case someone wants to try it, just drop me a line This is the list of League and cup winners and also managers who did the double on the 138 seasons we already played (I know, I know.... I'm abusing my position and advertising my league)
Another suggestion I have is to implement a bonus for playing against a TC and draw or win without using a TC yourself. A lot of managers in higher divisions are facing managers from lower divisions an get a lot of TCs against, making it very hard to counter all of them. Getting some extra medals for having good results in those matches seems more fair to me.
This is something that's already being considered
No promises, but who knows what future will bring btw I see that OSM staff is finally cleaning up the top ranking. keep it up!
Tks! As some of you know, we doesn't punish users without strong evidences and these cases require an access level to info that staff doesn't have, so it's always necessary the help of Gamebasics. This is why punishing these managers take longer than we would like and also why we prefer to work towards discourage this kind of cheating (an on going project) and educate our users!
@SpecialOne il play in one of your crew leagues, long as everything is off in the moderator tools
. See you ignored my comment completely as expected lmao. Give me a date, time and league and count me in -
Its nice to see we are finally getting some answers and explanations. Always nice to see that our "complaints" and suggestions are being at least looked in to and taken into consideration.
Anyway, I would like that all of us focus more on suggestions to improve the medal system in order that we have as much as possible fair system that will award competitiveness and activity. Focusing only on cheaters and focusing only on the fact that we dont like medal system will surelly not help to improve much.
So lets think about it and give some great suggestion, some people already tried to give some awesome feedback and suggestions, and there are some really great ideas here, lets keep it up!
-
@specialone said in Divisions - Discussion/Questions....:
Not really sure if this is the way to go. The only possibility I see here is to add another setting when requesting leagues, so league mods can enable/disable it. It will require also adjustments on signing up, because it will have to be clear that Medals are active or not. On the specific situation of crew battles, it will have to be ALL on or ALL off....
On a personal opinion I think that if we change, we should go for a change on calculation of win/draw/loss medals according with managers division and also end of season medals calculation.
I would say all off for crew battles, but I appreciate it's being considered.
Are you saying that "The Force" crew league is an easy league ? How many did you won in the 9 seasons you played there
? And don't forget that I always play with the lowest goal team on crew league
You should play a few more to make me lose 4K (2 * 2K) on every season
In case someone wants to try it, just drop me a line This is the list of League and cup winners and also managers who did the double on the 138 seasons we already played (I know, I know.... I'm abusing my position and advertising my league) no, I didn't say it was easy, only you win most of them (like your table shows ) I was close 1 or 2 times, but still suffer from it not winning once 
But always enjoyed playing it!
If I have time and a free slot I will certainly come and play more leagues
See @jeffro-davies already applied for the next oneThis is something that's already being considered
No promises, but who knows what future will bring Let's wait and see then
-
@dennis-s-bergkamp Albino wonβt reply to me but Iβm sure I could win it given the chance, thatβs if itβs fair.
-
Force & Friends leagues are always fair. No ST and TC used and no abuse of BC
( but you cannot expect anything else from staff members )I know @woopertje did join once and he couldn't manage it either, Although he had difficulty of having a goal 1.
-
@dennis-s-bergkamp said in Divisions - Discussion/Questions....:
I know @woopertje did join once and he couldn't manage it either, Although he had difficulty of having a goal 1.
We're playing now the 139th Season, we already had 104 different managers playing on it and only 36 different managers won it
But let's get back on topic, otherwise I'll have to warn/ban myself
-
@specialone said in Divisions - Discussion/Questions....:
@dennis-s-bergkamp said in Divisions - Discussion/Questions....:
I know @woopertje did join once and he couldn't manage it either, Although he had difficulty of having a goal 1.
We're playing now the 139th Season, we already had 104 different managers playing on it and only 36 different managers won it
But let's get back on topic, otherwise I'll have to warn/ban myself
Letβs make it 37
I see 5 CPUs in the current one. Sure you could make room for me in the next one. Think this is like the 20th message you have ignored me now over the last few monthsleast youβre talking to others and answering questions which is good. I wonβt ask again, il take the hint and wonβt talk about it anymore. -
Vinayak Singh Mehra English Usersreplied to Vinayak Singh Mehra on last edited by Vinayak Singh Mehra
@vinayak-singh-mehra said in Divisions - Discussion/Questions....:
Guys I've come up with a survey, please check it and answer your opinions.
https://forms.gle/zdr9FqoQCTVuQpJE7You can still use this guys.
-
- At the moment I get always the same number of medals if I beat a human manager, no matter which goal I'm or which goal he is. It's always the same...Till now most managers played with lower goals (goal 16, goal 13, goal 9 etc.) just in order to collect more MP's. Does it mean that with the removal of MP's club goals are becoming irrelevant? Why would I choose to manage WBA or Fulham in EPL? Ofc I will take ManCity or Liverpool...
Can you explain please...
On manager points system, the points you get to beat a goal 1 or a goal 16 is exactly the same, the difference lies on the end of season bonus (that's added on a daily basis on manager points and only at the end of season on Medals system). The bonus you get for finishing on a specific position depends on the goal of the team you played with!
I am really sorry to say, but this is just not true. By winning against a goal 1 team you earn MUCH more MPs than winning again a goal 16 team. NOT taking into account the end of season bonus added every day.
For me is really bad, if people who defend to cancel the existing system obviously do not EVEN KNOW how the existing system is working!
-
I have another issue, a kind of bug with the medals. i play all games and gain/loose medals for the games of the day. within the night there is an update of the app. then the following day, i "play" the games of the evening before again, and again gain/loose the medals of this games. so i gain/loose always twice, if there is an update (which is quite often).
does anyone else has the same problem?
-
I have a quite easy suggestion to solve the issue with losing medals if you play competetive leagues. in the settings of the league for the moderator should be added the possibility to switch of the medals. than it would be clear, that in this league you neither win nor loose medals, including the medals for the ending of the season.
-
@somrob
Now playing with teams with low objectives means loss of more medals. And most of all, you lose thrice the number of medals (which you get when you win a match) when you lose a match. I agree your point -
@vinayak-singh-mehra said in Divisions - Discussion/Questions....:
Now playing with teams with low objectives means loss of more medals
If you are a bad manager, you are sure to lose more medal points.
The only difference is that you get the same number of medal points when you take a club with obj 16 and obj 1, while with manager points it is not so. And if you want to be on top, you have to play with 4 slots -
@vinayak-singh-mehra said in Divisions - Discussion/Questions....:
Guys I've come up with a survey, please check it and answer your opinions.
https://forms.gle/zdr9FqoQCTVuQpJE7Hello everyone! The results of this survey will be given after this month ends. If you haven't have your opinion, then check it out!
-
@SpecialOne said:
There will never be a perfect system that please all users
...so we decided to create a system that almost everyone will hate
there was also a lot of cheating with old ranking, but that didn't ended up in such a fast climb in rankings which make it difficult to spot them, now with 4 slots adding together, it's easier to spot them and they will be caught/punished faster.
ladies and gentlemen, i want to introduce you to @ΡΠ°ΡΠΊΠΎΠΏ_1, Russia top-1 since the beginning of spring
if you wish, you can check the style of his play
On the technical side, old ranking system is becoming way too heavy for engines with the increase of number of users (keep in mind that every user have up to 4 entries on MP ranking system)
it's 2021... can anyone believe in this?
and my favorite:Just give it some time and you'll find out that medals will be more balanced and according to the manager level/skills
the winner of the strongest CIS league received a negative bonus according to its results
playing against a manager with a much stronger lineup, the system considers such a balance of points to be fair
maybe I'm wrong, but having the status of admin and forum moderator, one of your missions is to convey a message from the community to the developers
Based on the all-time low rating message, have you decided that everything is ok? I think you are useless to the community, but only contribute to the transformation of a good game (which is an important part of the lives of thousands of people around the world) into another casual shit from the playmarket. Bon Appetit. -
@wenger-wise This is the case, the game has become boring with the classification of medals
